The Scenario:
Recently my daughter was playing with some other children. One of the girls took the book Karissa was reading out of her hand instead of choosing a different book from the large stack sitting nearby. Karissa came to me and complained about this treatment (understandably). The other girl’s mom was in the room, but didn’t see the situation happen.
The Question:
What would YOU do?
My Answer at the Time:
I told Karissa to pick another book and let the other little girl have the book in question.
My Husband’s Gut Response:
Something like, “I don’t want my kid to be a push-over and get taken advantage of. You can’t ignore justice in a situation.”
So . . . the pondering began.
First, being “nice” in public is something society, especially Christian society, encourages. Was my response motivated by others watching me? But there’s also the idea of advocating for your child, letting them know you’re on their side. Did I drop the ball?
What does the Bible have to say on the issue? How about the biblical principle of “turning the other cheek”? “And if anyone forces you to go one mile, go with him two miles.” Do these principles apply to play dates and sharing books between three-year-olds? Can we apply, “Be kind to one another, tenderhearted, forgiving one another, as God in Christ forgave you”?
And yet, taken to an extreme, we find ourselves giving up all our possessions—money, homes, cars—to anyone who asks us. We find ourselves allowing others to trample us as humans and as individuals beloved by God. Is this truly what God is asking us to do? Is God telling us to do what reason screams is impossible? This response also denigrates the principle of justice. An impartial judge would not have made such a ruling.
My next thought was to ask for advice. I would ask all my friends and wise counselors what they thought I should do. That would be great! People love to offer advice! There must be a consensus I would like that we could reach together!
Then I decided to figure out for myself what I thought before asking others for advice. (And I am asking right now for your feedback.) Here’s the position I personally decided to teach my children:
1. Stand up for things that need to be defended. These include things that pertain to Christ, that is, the issues he would be fighting for if he were in my place. (Oh, you mean he wouldn’t fight for the last piece of cheesecake in my fridge right now?)
2. Stand up for people who need to be defended. When others are being treated unjustly, and it is within my ability to offer aid, I should be ready and able to do so.
3. Scrutinize closely the things I deem to be my “rights.”
4. Communicate effectively so that my treasures are not squandered on the unappreciative. (If it’s a special blanket to only one person, then the other person might easily be persuaded to accept an alternative one.)
If I truly love my child, I will teach her not to push for her own rights. I will also teach her that I do love her and that as her mother I will protect her and value her. Each situation will be different, but love and grace will be our guiding motivations.
Of course, this is the goal; making it happen is the rest of my parenting years. Figuring out what “protect” looks like, knowing what things make her feel valued, teaching her to deny herself even when it’s counterintuitive, discerning between things Christ would fight for and things that are more about me. Yep, still working on those things in my own life.
Scenarios are always nuanced and each one requires discernment. There a thousand qualifiers we could add to my opening story that would change the situation entirely. I’m not really asking you to judge this particular scene but to think instead to the broader principles. When would you choose to give up what’s yours? To seek justice? To defend? What do you want your child to learn?